No baker’s kitchen is full and not using a spherical cake pan. We pull one out for all of our favourite cake recipes, from classics like chocolate cake and pink velvet cake to towering layer desserts and the always-adorable Easter bunny cake. A spherical cake pan isn’t any one-trick pony, although, pulling double responsibility for baking issues like fluffy cinnamon rolls, dinner rolls, and even potato gratin.
However in relation to nailing that excellent cake — tall and fluffy, with a moist, tender crumb and even browning — you want an amazing cake pan. With a view to discover the very best of the very best, we spent hours placing a few of the hottest cake pans in the marketplace to the check, baking a number of several types of desserts, and judging how every pan’s materials, texture, and design options impacted its efficiency. Right here’s how they stacked up.
-
The Fats Daddio’s pan is made out of 16-gauge anodized aluminum, so it distributes warmth evenly, cools down rapidly, and is protected to make use of with acidic elements.
-
Since anodized aluminum heats quicker, some recipes baked on this pan could have to be adjusted barely, equivalent to baking at a decrease temperature for a couple of minutes longer.
It’s simple to see why Fats Daddio’s is the cake pan of selection for a lot of skilled bakers and pastry cooks throughout the nation. This pan was constantly a prime performer in our exams, turning out tall, fluffy, and evenly baked desserts with little to no doming that had been simply as moist across the edges as within the middle of the cake. The anodizing course of units this pan other than the competitors, because it helps the pan warmth evenly and funky down rapidly, so that you don’t have to fret a few cake overbaking as soon as it’s out of the oven. Anodizing additionally makes the cake pan protected to make use of with acidic elements like lemons, tomatoes, or buttermilk, so you should utilize it in recipes like our Buttermilk Cake with Blackberries with out breaking a sweat.
The Fats Daddio’s pan isn’t nonstick, however merely greasing and lining the pan with parchment paper makes it simple to launch desserts, breads, and cinnamon rolls, guaranteeing picture-perfect baked items and a straightforward cleanup in addition. Whereas the Fats Daddio’s pan could lack a few of the bells and whistles of its opponents, we discovered its easy development nonetheless checked all of the packing containers. The pan has a flat backside and straight sides — a should for layer desserts — and a thick rolled rim that makes it simple to grip with oven mitts when transferring the pan out and in of the oven or flipping onto a cooling rack. At lower than $15 every, this pan is a downright steal, and it’s additionally out there in a variety of widths and depths for all of your baking wants.
Dimensions: 9 x 2 inches | Materials: Anodized aluminum | Dishwasher–protected: No | Scratch–Proof: No
-
The pan’s nonstick coating is freed from doubtlessly poisonous elements like PTFE, PFOA, and BPA and makes it simple to launch recipes and clear.
USA Pan’s spherical cake pan is one other dependable possibility so as to add to your kitchen, significantly when you’re looking for out a nonstick pan. Constituted of heavy gauge aluminized metal, this pan contains a ribbed, fluted floor that helps improve air circulation, resulting in extra even warmth distribution and, in flip, desserts which are baked uniformly from the middle to the sides. In our exams, the pan repeatedly baked evenly browned desserts that prevented important doming. Due to the model’s patented Americoat silicone coating — which is freed from PTFE, PFOA, and BPA — baked items like cake and focaccia effortlessly popped out of the pan, which can be simple to wash.
Dimensions: 9 x 2 inches | Materials: Aluminized metal | Dishwasher–protected: No | Scratch–Proof: No
-
This trendy pan is offered in a number of eye-catching colours, like marigold, sage, and perracotta, making it nice for gifting.
-
At $40, the Caraway circle pan is the most costly of the pans we examined, although plenty of options assist justify its greater price ticket.
The Caraway circle pan was one of the vital enticing cake pans we examined, however we had been extra impressed with how properly the pan carried out, baking desserts with a young crumb and little to no doming. Constituted of aluminized metal, the pan contains a flat backside, straight sides, and a skinny flat rim. The pan’s ceramic coating, which is freed from doubtlessly poisonous supplies together with PTFE, PFOA, PFAs, and heavy metals, makes the floor nonstick, so baked items effortlessly launch from the pan, and it’s additionally simple to scrub by hand. Whereas nonstick coatings are famously simple to scratch, the coating on the Caraway pan held up surprisingly properly all through our exams. The pan also can face up to greater temperatures than many different pans — it’s oven-safe as much as 550°F — making it a worthy funding for a variety of recipes.
Dimensions: 9 x 2 inches | Materials: Aluminized metal | Dishwasher–protected: No | Scratch–Proof: Sure
All through our testing, desserts baked within the Cuisinart spherical cake pan, which is made out of heavy gauge aluminized metal with straight sides and a rolled rim, prevented the dreaded dome. The pan has a Whitford Xylan nonstick coating on each its inside and exterior, which each simply releases baked items and makes for simple cleanup. The draw back? This pan didn’t distribute warmth as evenly as a few of the different pans in our exams, resulting in inconsistently browned — and in some instances, overbaked — desserts, which had been additionally barely denser as a result of pan’s shorter sides. That stated, its cheaper price tag nonetheless makes it a stable possibility for residence bakers seeking to buy a number of pans without delay to make layer desserts.
Dimensions: 9.49 x 1.69 inches | Materials: Aluminized metal | Dishwasher–protected: Sure | Scratch–Proof: No
Our Favourite Cake Pan
Fats Daddio’s cake pans are sometimes named-checked by skilled bakers and pastry cooks and our testing helped illustrate why. Whether or not baking pillowy focaccia, fluffy cinnamon rolls, or mild and ethereal cake layers, this pan rose above the competitors — typically actually. With its superior anodized coating and reasonably priced price ticket, we’d suggest the Fats Daddio’s Anodized Aluminum Spherical Cake Pan to bakers of all ability ranges.
Components to Think about
Materials
Materials is arguably crucial issue to think about when choosing out a spherical cake pan. {Many professional} bakers go for aluminized metal resulting from its sturdiness and even warmth conductivity, which helps to forestall sizzling spots and ensures baked items that rise evenly, avoiding the dreaded dome. Pastry chef and Extra Than Cake creator Natasha Pickowicz says to keep away from glass cake pans, as the fabric tends to conduct warmth extra slowly. “I by no means bake in glass as a result of I simply do not suppose you are gonna get as even or robust of a bake,” she says.
Like many pastry cooks, Pickowicz prefers cake pans made with anodized aluminum, a ending course of that makes these pans extra sturdy and proof against scratching. The anodizing course of additionally offers pans a stage of nonstick high quality, serving to baked items launch simply from the pan and making cleanup a breeze, and retains the metallic from reacting to acidic elements like lemons or tomatoes and leaching into your meals.
“With one thing like anodized aluminum, it is light-weight, and the batter is coming into contact with the warmth of the oven extra effectively, and throughout it too — not simply on prime, however beneath,” Pickowicz says. “Anodized aluminum is admittedly what you are seeing in each single bakery, restaurant, kitchen. They’re baking tons of of desserts a day — they know what works.”
Nonstick
Pickowicz recommends steering away from nonstick cake pans, because the nonstick end can simply be nicked when eradicating the cake from the pan. “I all the time inform folks to not spend money on nonstick something, however particularly for baking desserts,” Pickowicz says. “Whenever you’re attempting to take away the cake or baked good from the nonstick pan, it is very easy to nick or chip the end, after which it is actually simply trash at that time. It’s laborious to handle them and there’s nothing that a bit cooking spray or butter within the pan received’t do for you.”
In case you do go for a nonstick cake pan — that are, it’s value noting, handy and simple to wash — be sure to observe the producer’s directions to protect the nonstick end so long as doable. Regardless, you need to nonetheless keep away from nonstick pans when baking recipes like chiffon cake or angel meals cake wherein the batter must grip onto the edges of the pan to rise correctly. “That is why for a chiffon or genoise sponge, you may not even grease the pan since you do not wish to scale back the friction; you wish to improve it so it is grippy,” Pickowicz says. “With nonstick, you actually lose that chance.”
Measurement
Spherical cake pans are available in many sizes, however 8- and 9-inch pans are commonplace for residence bakers. “I believe it is necessary to have each an 8-inch and a 9-inch spherical cake pan, and 1 / 4 sheet pan for sheet desserts,” says baker and cookbook creator Pleasure Wilson of Pleasure the Baker. Whichever dimension you select, be sure to search for a cake pan with straight sides to make sure uniformity when assembling layer desserts.
Floor
Some cake pans have textured surfaces, that are stated to extend air circulation, aiding in warmth distribution and evenly baking desserts from the facilities out to the sides. In our exams, we seen pans with textured surfaces, equivalent to grooves or ridges, additionally cleanly launched baked items and had been significantly simple handy wash.
How We Examined Cake Pans
After researching the market, we narrowed our exams down to 6 in style 9-inch cake pans, which we evaluated primarily based on their efficiency, sturdiness, and ease of cleansing. We checked out elements together with the pan’s materials, texture, design options, and, if relevant, nonstick floor, after which evaluated how these elements impacted the pan’s efficiency in a sequence of exams.
To evaluate every pan’s efficiency subsequent to the opposite, we baked the identical recipes in every pan — each cake, together with a primary white cake, a boxed yellow cake, and our Greatest-Ever Birthday Cake — and non-cake, equivalent to our pillowy focaccia. We regarded intently at how every pan baked these recipes, judging whether or not or not the inside of the cake was baked completely and evenly, if the skin of the cake was an excellent golden-brown shade, and if the cake had a pronounced dome, indicating uneven heating all through the pan.
To check the sturdiness of every pan, we thought-about elements like the very best oven temperature the pan is suitable with and checked out whether or not or not working a metallic utensil throughout the floor broken the pan’s floor or, if relevant, its nonstick coating. We additionally judged how simply the cake and focaccia launched from the pan, noting if any a part of the baked items caught to the pan, and the way simple the pan was to wash.
Different Cake Pans We Examined
The cake pans highlighted above carried out the very best all through our exams, however we discovered a number of others additionally value a point out. Though they fell quick in a number of of our exams, these pans would nonetheless be stable choices in your kitchen. Right here’s what we favored — and the place we noticed room for enchancment.
Nice Jones Patty Cake Pan ($30 at Nice Jones)
Nice Jones’ Patty Cake pan is simple on the eyes — it’s out there in three daring colours (raspberry, broccoli, and blueberry) and has a wavy, corrugated floor that helps simply launch baked items. We discovered this pan to be a bit inconsistent, although, baking a superbly browned spherical of focaccia but in addition barely underbaking desserts in a number of exams. Whereas the nonstick coating made for a straightforward cleanup, it didn’t maintain up properly towards metallic utensils and rapidly obtained nicked.
Williams Sonoma Traditionaltouch Spherical Cake Pan ($25 at Williams Sonoma)
Made with aluminized metal, the Traditionaltouch Spherical Cake Pan from Williams Sonoma is a basic possibility, with a flat floor, straight sides, and a thick rolled edge. This pan additionally proved a bit unreliable, performing properly in some exams however yielding underbaked or domed desserts in others. The pan doesn’t have a nonstick coating and, even when greased and lined with parchment paper, a number of recipes caught to its floor in spots.
Our Experience
- Heather Riske is a St. Louis-based author and editor with over a decade of expertise in meals and life-style content material. For practically eight years, she labored as an editor at Feast Journal, a regional culinary publication masking the state of Missouri, southern Illinois, and jap Kansas, the place she was honored with a “High Girls in Media” award by Folio. She has devoted a lot of her profession to highlighting native cooks and eating places and sharing useful cooking data for publications equivalent to Higher Properties & Gardens, Males’s Well being, Feast Journal, and St. Louis Journal. For this piece, she examined ten of the very best cake pans in side-by-side testing.
- For extra insights, Riske additionally spoke with baker and cookbook creator, Pleasure Wilson, of Pleasure the Baker.