Ye, previously Kanye West’s sonic spellbinding has had followers hanging onto each beat, each bar, each completely miscalculated controversy. Those that pledged allegiance from day one might recite his discography like a scripture. However the maestro of music and mayhem has lengthy swapped strategic album rollouts for inflammatory tirades on X, leaving the world debating whether or not his genius nonetheless outshines the chaos. But, regardless of how turbulent his trajectory is, when Ye speaks, the tradition listens, and when he drops, the arguments ignite. His elusive albums stay in limbo however one query refuses to fade, does ‘Ye’ eclipse ‘My Stunning Darkish Twisted Fantasy’?
For these searching for the last word rating of Ye’s sonic legacy, here’s a rundown of each album.
16. Vultures 2 (2024)
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues under this advert
The extra ‘Vultures 2’ lingers in dialog, the extra it echoes the heartbreak of an unfinished saga, conjuring the ghosts of what might have been. What ought to have marked a triumphant return for Ye as a substitute unraveled right into a storm of leaks, stripping the mission of its edge earlier than it might even take flight.
To make issues worse, Ye’s flirtation with AI has solely deepened the album’s controversy, blurring the road between inventive ingenuity and artistic dilution. Whereas critics already branded it the worst album of 2024, the true wound lies in its failure to seize the untamed, era-defining essence that followers had been ready for.
15. Donda 2 (2022)
Although ‘Donda 2’ by no means made it to the DSPs, it sparked anticipation with its restricted STEM launch. Nevertheless, regardless of boasting hip-hop heavyweights on the report, the album’s chaotic incoming earned removed from the reception anticipated.
From lackluster hooks to the absence of phonetic caliber, the report’s anthems weren’t near its prequel. Certain, there have been highlights like ‘Eazy’ and ‘Metropolis of Gods’ that immortalized themselves on individuals’s playlists, simply as many tracks fell off the grid like ‘Safety.’
14. Jesus is King (2019)
When the information broke out about Ye going behind the jukebox for a Christian album, ‘Jesus is King,’ even the followers feared the worst, not to mention critics. Though followers anticipated nothing lower than a firestorm of expletives, when the album lastly dropped, it eclipsed expectations with tracks like ‘Comply with God’ and ‘God Is.’
The musical backdrop was purely eccentric however in the end, the report fell in need of his lyrical prowess. Though it’s positively not the worst on his plate, it’s extra private and fewer about Jesus, who he tries to deal with.
Whereas Ye has a knack for treating his music individually, this report was exempted from the formidable reception the others discovered.
13. Vultures 1 (2024)
‘Vultures 1’ was the primary album Ye joined forces with Ty Dolla $ign for after his inventive hiatus, pledging a comeback for the books. Nevertheless, controversy adopted his coattails because the album got here sizzling on the heels of his antisemitic burst out and erratic perspective. When the album dropped after a number of delays, the report was abuzz on each potential playlist, drawing even A-listers to his listening experiences.
‘Carnival’ grew to become a Billboard topper whereas North West made her debut with ‘Speaking,’ turning a brand new web page to Ye’s legacy. But, what was additionally plentiful was the lowlights of the report with tracks like ‘Hoodrat’ and ‘Do It’ falling out of his signature symphonic advantage.
12. Ye (2018)
Each Ye entry has been stuffed with drama and ‘Ye,’ his eighth studio album was truthfully no exception. The report was reportedly completely reworked after the rapper’s notorious run-in with TMZ, and upon its launch, the push was seen. Though there was debate about whether or not it eclipses ‘My Stunning Darkish Twisted Fantasy,’ it’s secure to say that it actually doesn’t. ‘
Ye’ was method rawer than polished however delivered a meteoric hit, ‘Ghost City.’ Nevertheless, his induction of alienated real-life references made the report lack the beats and move often plentiful in his different data, revealing a thematic void of connectivity, rendering one thing extra haphazard than concrete.
11. Merciless Summer time (2012)
‘Merciless Summer time,’ like loads of Ye’s data, boasts superhit tracks nonetheless instilled in popular culture’s consciousness. The G.O.O.D. Music album has had its justifiable share of critics however smash hits like ‘Mercy, ‘Chilly,’ and ‘New God Circulate,’ converse in any other case.
Though it’s not thought-about among the many high 10 of Ye’s albums, citing the absence of goal and distinction, it is likely one of the choose few albums whose tracks retain a everlasting place in his fandom’s collective reminiscence.
10. Youngsters See Ghosts (2018)
‘Youngsters See Ghosts’ noticed one of the vital highlighted collaborations of the hip-hop kingdom, the primary ever between Child Cudi and Ye. Clocked at 24 minutes. The album flexes the inventive conjunction of the 2 at peaks. Ye didn’t solely leverage star energy and Cudi’s rapping abilities along with his personal, however made a completed piece of essential acclaim, capitalizing on the emotionally charged Kurt Cobain pattern.
The report reeked of classic Ye, one thing the followers are nonetheless scratching their heads looking for.
9. Donda (2021)
‘Donda’s’ rollout was the height of hip-hop and an unforgettable spotlight season for his fandom. Regardless of curating a launch get together in Atlanta, Ye stored transforming the album, fueled with shut consideration to suggestions from the followers worldwide.
He then adopted three back-to-back listening events earlier than the discharge, delivering absolute standouts like ‘Hurricane,’ ‘Off the Grid,’ and ‘Imagine What I Say.’ Nevertheless, the one place the report most likely lacked was in modifying when the rapper refused to chop down the album to a concise tracklist.
8. Yeezus (2013)
Ye’s ‘Yeezus’ might not be the preferred album from his discography, but it surely obtained rave evaluations, debuting at #1 on the Billboard 200 and making related chart success throughout 31 nations. Though the album obtained two nominations on the Grammy Awards in 2014, it was designed for defamiliarization, and it delivered.
Confrontational, divisive, and purely a departure from the hip-hop mould of latest occasions, ‘Yeezus’ was a welcomed exception on each entrance.
7. The Lifetime of Pablo (2016)
From right here onwards, Ye’s legacy solely goes up and onwards. The rapper joined forces with Child Cudi, Probability the Rapper, Kelly Value, and Kirk Franklin, leading to a milestone product of absolutely the dream staff. Though rendered a messy album, ‘The Lifetime of Pablo,’ was a drive to reckon with.
It was cathartically constructed with an ambition that delivered. The report appeared on a number of year-end lists of the perfect albums of the 12 months. It’s also extra profitable when it comes to Grammy nominations than ‘Yeezus,’ ‘My Stunning Darkish Twisted Fantasy,’ and ‘808s & Heartbreak.’
6. Watch the Throne (2011)
‘Watch the Throne’ was a collaborative album between Ye and Jay-Z that reiterated a strong comeback narrative. With innovation at its forefront, the titans brushed genius and brilliance with the end result of their brotherhood and inventive caliber.
The report was nearly every thing the followers wished and hip-hop wanted to maintain the revolution going. Its ‘Otis’ observe earned them a Grammy, whereas delivering electrifying songs like ‘Ni—s in Paris,’ ‘Primetime,’ and ‘Raise Off.’
5. 808s & Heartbreak (2008)
Credited as one of the vital influential Ye data of all time, ‘808s & Heartbreak’ has typically joined debates whether or not it might sit on the throne for good. The report was an emotional rollercoaster, not only for the rapper however for the supposed viewers who discovered themselves resonating strongly with it.
It debuted atop the Billboard 200, obtained fairly the honors together with platinum certifications, and garnered essential acclaim. Among the hottest tracks embody ‘Heartless,’ and ‘See you in My Nightmares,’ however by this album, Ye revolutionized the scope of auto-tune—one thing he has failed along with his endorsement of AI.
4. Late Registration (2006)
Ye’s ‘Late Registration’ was a milestone report, debuting on #1 on the US Billboard 200. The album obtained five-times platinum certification from the RIAA and earned 8 whopping nominations on the forty eighth Grammy Awards, profitable the Finest Rap Album.
Tracks like ‘Diamonds From Sierra Leone,’ ‘Contact the Sky, and ‘Hey Mama,’ flexed his good hooks, and the perfect half is the report grew to become a timeless piece of his extravagant discography.
3. The School Dropout (2004)
From the Grammy Awards to industrial success, Ye’s ‘The School Dropout’ noticed all of it. The report received three Grammies, witnessed penultimate Billboard success, and bought over 3.4 million copies by the last decade’s compilation.
The rapper didn’t simply hit the bullseye with its industrial enchantment but in addition its distinctive thematic method, rendering it as one of many best albums of all time by Time and Rolling Stone.
2. Commencement (2007)
It was the latter half of the last decade, that means Ye had already warmed as much as the methods of the highlight. ‘Commencement’ debuted at primary on the US Billboard 200, and has been licensed a septuple platinum by RIAA. Tracks like ‘Stronger,’ ‘Good Life,’ and ‘Homecoming’ landed on the apex of the US Billboard Sizzling 100.
The spotlight, nonetheless, was the way it bought Ye his third Grammy for Finest Rap Album alongside his third nomination for Album of the Yr. The report was a mixture inspiration of stadium excursions, home music and indie-rock, marking fairly a defamiliarization from his earlier compositions.
It might have been experimental but it surely was one of many standout albums the followers nonetheless have fun in the present day.
1. My Stunning Darkish Twisted Fantasy (2010)
‘Commencement’ might have felt like Ye was dwelling in his personal era-defining second however ‘My Stunning Darkish Twisted Fantasy’ modified all of it. Nowhere near ‘Ye’s’ blended reception, the album witnessed Ye’s inventive zenith not like every other, incomes him the Finest Rap Album on the Grammys that 12 months.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues under this advert
Whereas its chart efficiency wants no point out, Ye rolled out back-to-back hits from Áll of the Lights’ to ‘Monster’ by ‘So Appalled,’ ‘Runaway,’ and so forth. Though critics have noticed voids inside move, creativity, modifying, and efficiency all through the rapper’s discography, ‘My Stunning Darkish Twisted Fantasy’ was an all-rounder in all facets.
ADVERTISEMENT
Article continues under this advert
Do you assume ‘Ye’ is best than ‘My Stunning Darkish Twisted Fantasy’? Tell us within the feedback under!
