Understanding protocol alien to PH

VP Sara Duterte composite picture from Inquirer file photograph

MANILA, Philippines—Vice President Sara Duterte’s latest declaration of herself because the “designated survivor” has ignited a wave of controversy and debate amongst authorities officers, lawmakers, and the general public.

Final July 11, in an ambush interview, Duterte instructed reporters that she is not going to attend the third State of the Nation Tackle (Sona) of President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. on July 22. She didn’t disclose any motive or clarification for her plan to skip Marcos’ upcoming Sona.

Nevertheless, she confused: “I’m appointing myself because the designated survivor.”

Her assertion, which for some might come off as an surprising announcement, has raised questions on its implications and the rationale behind it, prompting many to ask: Does the idea of getting a chosen survivor apply to the Philippines, and the way wouldn’t it impression the Sona.

What’s a ‘designated survivor’?

Some could acknowledge the time period from the equally titled fictional thriller TV present, which facilities round Tom Kirkman—portrayed by actor Kiefer Sutherland —a lower-level Cupboard member who unexpectedly ascends to the presidency after a catastrophic assault wipes out america (US) president and a lot of the Cupboard.

Traditionally, within the US, the time period designated survivor refers to a high-ranking official within the presidential line of succession who’s stored at a safe, undisclosed location throughout disastrous occasions.

Normally, the designated survivor is escorted by Secret Service to an undisclosed location earlier than the State of the Union Tackle together with the “Soccer” — a 45-pound briefcase containing top-secret nuclear launch codes.

This precaution ensures continuity of presidency, permitting the designated survivor to imagine the presidency if a catastrophic incident incapacitates the President, Vice President, and different high officers.

Whereas it’s unclear precisely when the follow began, historians imagine the designated survivor protocol originated in the course of the administration of US President Dwight D. Eisenhower within the Nineteen Fifties. This era, marked by the Chilly Conflict, noticed the introduction of “continuity of presidency” measures as a response to the potential risk of Soviet nuclear strikes on Washington, D.C.., the US capital the place the White Home and Capitol are situated.

The protocol was designed to make sure that authorities management would endure even within the occasion of a devastating strike.

GRAPHIC BY ED LUSTAN

In keeping with a report revealed by the HISTORY Channel, the primary publicly acknowledged designated survivor was US Secretary of Training Terrel Bell, who didn’t attend then-President Ronald Reagan’s deal with to a joint session of Congress in 1981.

Nevertheless, Bell’s function because the designated survivor wasn’t disclosed till a few years later. In reality, it wasn’t till 1984 that the White Home began publicly naming the designated survivor on the day of the State of the Union Tackle.

The time period designated survivor isn’t formally utilized by the White Home; as a substitute, they confer with the person as “the Cupboard member not in attendance.”

The identification of the very first designated survivor stays categorized. The Senate Historic Workplace has beforehand famous that the follow of getting a Cupboard member absent from the State of the Union Tackle dates again to a minimum of the early Sixties, and presumably even earlier.

Who will get to be a chosen survivor?

Public data confirmed that there have been over 50 designated survivors for the reason that follow started within the US. Luckily, no designated survivor has ever needed to assume the presidency attributable to an assault throughout a State of the Union Tackle or different main occasion.

In keeping with the Congressional Analysis Service, typically, one member of the US President’s Cupboard is chosen because the designated survivor. Nevertheless, not each Cupboard member will get chosen to fill the function.

One of many key situations for a chosen survivor is that the individual ought to meet the 2 fundamental eligibility necessities for the US presidency: being a minimum of 35 years previous and a natural-born US citizen.

Prior to now, notable Cupboard members not born within the US, corresponding to Secretary of State Madeleine Okay. Albright, didn’t qualify to turn out to be designated survivors.

The Congressional Analysis Service additionally famous that “[t]he designated survivor has most ceaselessly been a Secretary from the Departments of Inside, Agriculture, and Commerce (although different government department division heads have been designated, as nicely.”

The individual chosen as designated survivor additionally needed to bear some undisclosed particular coaching to organize for the potential of assuming the US presidency.

In 2014, former Well being and Human Companies Secretary Donna Shalala, who served as a chosen survivor beneath then-President Invoice Clinton in 1996, instructed ABC Information: “They walked you thru the White Home and confirmed you the State of affairs Room and talked critically in regards to the accountability of the designated survivor.”

Whereas some details about the function and duties of a chosen survivor has been disclosed through the years, many elements stay categorized. These chosen for this crucial function are sometimes sworn to secrecy to make sure the safety and effectiveness of the protocol.

It’s also stated that the designated survivor doesn’t mechanically turn out to be president. If one other official increased within the line of succession survives an assault, that particular person would assume the presidency as a substitute.

The designated survivor’s function is a contingency measure, guaranteeing somebody is at all times accessible to steer if the first leaders are incapacitated.

‘No such factor’ in PH

Whereas the protocol has been a long-standing follow within the US, there isn’t a such factor as a chosen survivor within the Philippines.

“I feel she is simply joking … as a result of we would not have such factor as a chosen survivor. Within the US, there’s. You might have seen the sequence on US TV; they’ve a chosen survivor — a Cupboard official, a Cupboard secretary is not going to be attending the Sona, and the individual is secluded,” stated Home of Representatives Secretary Basic Reginald Velasco.

“After which no matter occurs to the president and the speedy successors—as a result of within the US Sona, like us, the vice chairman is there who’s the pinnacle of the Senate, after which the chief justice of the Supreme Courtroom, the speaker of the Home, so the speedy successors are all attending the [Sona] that’s the reason they’ve the so-called designated survivor,” he added.

Though the Philippine authorities doesn’t adhere to a chosen survivor protocol, Article VII of the 1987 Structure clearly outlines the road of succession within the occasion that the sitting president dies or turns into completely incapacitated.

Part 7 states that the Vice President will succeed the President if “in the beginning of the time period of the President, the President-elect shall have died or shall have turn out to be completely disabled.” The Vice President may even be President to serve the unexpired time period of the President “in case of demise, everlasting incapacity, removing from workplace, or resignation.”

READ: VP Duterte as ‘designated survivor’? No such factor in PH – Home SecGen

Payments on designated successor have been filed in Congress, however these haven’t been enacted. Amongst these was a invoice filed by former Senator Panfilo Lacson in 2019, authorizing the President to call a chosen survivor.

READ: Lacson pushes for passage of invoice naming President’s ‘designated survivor’

GRAPHIC BY ED LUSTAN

In keeping with Camiguin Rep. Jurdin Jesus Romualdo, this might be the primary time that an official has boasted of being a chosen survivor previously State of the Nation Tackle (Sona) and used this as a motive to skip the occasion.

READ: Sara Duterte instructed to cease spending an excessive amount of time on Netflix

“Within the many years value of Sonas that we’ve had, no person has ever flaunted being the ‘designated survivor’ and used it because the excuse to skip the necessary occasion. Correct decorum and custom say that the Vice President must be there in plenary at Batasan to listen to the great President’s report back to the nation,” Romualdo famous.

“That is among the many political situations that take a backseat to transparency and unbridled communication with the general public. Vice President Duterte’s predecessors did this with no concern whereas in workplace. One would suppose that she would additionally attempt to attain that commonplace,” he added.

Veiled risk?

Duterte’s designated survivor assertion—which has been described by many as a “very unhealthy joke”—drew ire and concern from a number of lawmakers, with some even calling her out for having a “delulu” (slang for delusional) habits or advising her to chorus from “spending an excessive amount of time watching Netflix” and as a substitute learn the Structure.

READ: Sara Duterte as ‘designated survivor’? She should be ‘delulu’ – group

Nevertheless, critics stated the statements might be a veiled risk and that it appeared to suggest that one thing incorrect may occur to the nation’s leaders, who would attend the Sona.

“The Vice President’s remarks about being the ‘designated survivor’ are each inappropriate and reckless. Such rhetoric hints at situations which might be alarming and baseless, sowing pointless concern among the many public,” stated Isabela Rep. Inno Dy V.

Lawmakers additionally confused that the vice chairman’s assertion is inappropriate and induces concern among the many public.

“Jokes about nationwide safety and succession aren’t any laughing matter. The Vice President must be setting an instance of management and accountability, not creating pointless panic,” Lanao del Sur Rep. Zia Alonto Adiong added.

READ: ‘Reckless’: Home solons slam VP Duterte’s ‘designated survivor’ comment

Duterte, nonetheless, just lately defined that her self-appointment as a chosen survivor was neither “a joke nor a bomb risk.”

“It’s not a joke, and it’s not a bomb risk both. I feel many missed the purpose. So for me, for those who didn’t perceive the primary time, I don’t suppose [you] deserve a proof,” she stated in an interview final July 17.

READ: Duterte on her ‘designated survivor’ comment: ‘Not a joke, bomb risk’

Absent, not watching Sona

On July 22, hours earlier than Marcos Jr. delivered his speech, the Workplace of the Vice President (OVP) launched an announcement saying that Duterte—who stayed true to her phrases and was absent from the occasion—wouldn’t watch the Sona by way of tv or on-line stay stream.

“She is at present in Bohol to empathize with the Boholanos for the demise of their Vice Governor, in addition to to uplift the overall temper of the individuals caused by the suspension of their duly-elected native officers,” it added.

The OVP defined that Duterte’s presence in Bohol additionally coincided with the province’s celebration of Bohol Day.

“It’s also Bohol Day at this time, which makes it an opportune time for the Vice President to convey a message of hope—na could Diyos na nagbabantay sa atin, at sa pamamagitan ng pagtutulungan at pagsisikap, magagawa nating ayusin ang Bayan muli.”

READ: VP Duterte received’t be watching Marcos’ third Sona – OVP

RELATED STORIES: 

Lacson says Designated Survivor Invoice a constitutional mandate

Filipinos: Designated Survivors

Pimentel on Sara Duterte’s ‘designated survivor’ quip: A foul joke

VP Duterte instructed: Marcos’ safety not a ‘joking matter’

Go to our Sona 2024 stay protection to remain up to date with the newest #SONA2024 information and tales.